Friday, September 27th, 2002
The Virtue of Engineering Cynicism
Cynics believe there is an ideal that humans choose not to live up to. For engineers, the ideals often are those of rationality: they like their work relationships characterized by the interchange of objective information unsullied by subjective, selfish motivations.
Dave Winer comments that
I think the correct word is skeptic. Or if you’re British, sceptic. And when he talks about programmers telling the truth, that’s something else entirely. “You can’t lie to the compiler.” People with an imprecise understanding of the truth don’t make software. They can’t.
I work in Test Engineering, where sceptisism is developed to a fine artform. We don’t believe any claim about a product unless we can measure it, and we don’t believe our own measurements unless we can trace the uncertainties back to national standards. Interestingly, there seems to be a disproportionally high number of Christians in this field. Perhaps it’s because as professional sceptics we tend to have a realistic view of human — and particulary our own — nature. The Bible provides traceability of our own deviation from the Divine standard.