Thursday, January 30th, 2003
A Slate report on the Davos summit raises the question “What is Yuk?”
When it comes to thinking about how to regulate the science, the
best test may be the “yuck factor.” This is, as you might imagine, a pretty
squishy concept, something along the lines of using gut reaction as a proxy for
a long and unproductive philosophical debate. Perhaps if people are grossed out
by, say, vat-grown artificial organs, they may not be ready to use them wisely.
Indeed, their gag reflex may be telling us something about the essence of human
nature and what might threaten it.Fair enough; plenty of laws attempt to
reflect the sensibilities of society. But the problem with applying revulsion to
science, explained Dr. Baltimore, an esteemed cell biologist who is the president
of CalTech, is that it’s all awfully hard to pin down. The reason:
“Yuck is culturally determined.”
Romans 12:2 is a good place to start.